Catgirl has gone straight, renouncing her criminal ways. However, some in the superhero community have their doubts about the former villainies' change of heart. Batchick is particularly skeptical and has been following Catgirl, waiting for her to slide back into her former self. It didn't take long before she discovers Catchick breaking into a home. Confronting Catgirl, Batchick isn't interested in her explanations and immediately pounces. No slouch, Catgirl fights back, finally catching Batchick with a spray of the Jester's laughing gas. Reducing to helpless laughter, Batchick is now in Catgirl's hands and the ex-villainess is going to teach the little heroine a lesson. Waking, Batchick is subjected to Catgirl's tickling nails and is punished with merciless tickling on her exposed soles and helpless upper body. To add a finishing touch, Catgirl, working up a thirst, dribbles milk on Batchick's feet and licks the poor heroines soles clean, driving Batchick wild with moans. Freeing Batchick after her punishment, Catgirl is taken by surprise by her own trap and soon she is in Batchick's hands. The heroine intends to get her revenge and gives the ex-villainess the same tickling torture she was given. Tickling with feathers, fronds and nails, she makes Catgirl scream with laughter and beg for mercy as her whole body is tickled.